Security Seal Facebook Twitter GooglePlus Pinterest Newsletter Sign-up
The Wall
Gordy

Gordy

Joined on October 13, 2004

Last Post on July 21, 2014

Contact User

Recent Posts

Other Areas

@ December 5, 2004 7:44 PM in Conductive Concrete???

Thats what I mean buy other areas Dan.But in my eyes a swavy consumer would not limit the ability to heat the dwelling to the emitters being lashed to electricity as a sole means to power them. At least with hydronics you can choose your heat plant to use the cheapest form of fuel and if that changes in the future you can roll with the change as long as it is cost effective. Until electricity can be produced at a cheaper rate maybe never, maybe through the CO-Generation avenue with the use of the stirling engine it could be. I think electric resistance heat of any kind on a residential scale in a dwelling is not going to be cheap until then. We already have it but cost to operate is why its not as popular. Gordy

Other Areas

@ December 5, 2004 7:34 PM in Conductive Concrete???

> more for radiant slabs in homes.

Conductive Concrete

@ December 5, 2004 12:06 PM in Conductive Concrete???

Being in the bridge construction industry for 21 years,I can say this is a high tech. Cost prohibitive system that is just being studied. Implementing it on a large scale will be tough. A 150' bridge is not squat at 3000 kwh per hour,power consumption. Salt,fuel and manpower is way cheaper over a time period they have to do the road anyway. Also to just do the bridge under the pretense we are preventing corrosion from salts is a myth,the salt will be carried from the roadway onto the bridge. This is not to say that the technology will not have some potential on a smaller scale in other areas, and applications. JMHO Gordy

@ December 1, 2004 12:13 PM in Combustion Air

Wondering what?

:)

@ November 30, 2004 11:00 PM in Combustion Air

I took it as being direct not curt,I like that. Well I have a gas fired Weil McClain. My only thought on this was I have four fireplaces and if I light Two I trip the spill switch on the draft hood if the boiler decides to cycle not good I know. So I went to opening the basement window a crack when burning which solved the problem.Guess I tightened up the house a little more than it liked. there fore I would like to do something a little more automatic. Sounds like your boiler is made to do the modification. Gordy

Costantin

@ November 30, 2004 10:24 PM in Combustion Air

I'm only asking the question. Not implieing that would be the case.Just a thought I had. Thanks for the info.:)

Question

@ November 30, 2004 5:31 PM in Combustion Air

If we induce outside combustion air say -15* would this not pose a worse condensation scenerio with in a CI atmospheric boiler? Versus using ambient air from the dwelling. I would like to do this also but this was a concern for me. I guess it would be mixing with ambient air somewhat,depending on the setup since it would not be sealed combustion in the true form. Gordy

Mark

@ November 29, 2004 5:51 AM in Is college best for everyone?

So, did you solve the problem Mark?

Mark

@ November 29, 2004 5:39 AM in Is college best for everyone?

> Great question. Is the group of college educated
> persons generally better problem solvers not
> because of college learning, but because better
> problem solving persons simply chose college in
> the first place?
>
> Who the heck knows!
>
> I will
> say this: Just the other day, I was called in by
> the owner to troubleshoot an expensive home's
> newly constructed $250k addition which had
> various radiant heat problems. I had lengthy
> conversations with the old timer who improperly
> (in my view) installed a radiant heat system into
> this 90 year old house.
>
> The improper piping
> was at once apparent and was in direct conflict
> with every manufacturer's documentation which I
> showed him. Yet, nothing could shake him. He
> was simply unable to join me in a discussion of
> the water path and determination of the various
> flows and pressures. He was unwilling to look at
> the papers I brought. He couldn't engage in a
> back and forth discussion. All he could say was
> "let me call Wirsbo". He could not theoretically
> trace in his head the changes I requested he
> make. He installed the stuff, as I told him, on
> the basis of plumbing folklore, not based on the
> manufacturers instruction sheets or on accepted
> hydronic principles.
>
> I asked for a copy of his
> heatloss calculations, he wouldn't give them to
> me. I asked for his construction drawings or
> sketches, there weren't any. I asked for this,
> for that, nothing. I asked for the length of pex
> he installed in each zone, couldn't tell me,
> etc.
>
> I hate generalizing about persons and
> their education, but I seem to bump into these
> kinds of guys all the time!

John

@ November 28, 2004 1:47 PM in Is college best for everyone?

Well said John! Funny how in todays society in can pay very well to be incompetent.... With the help of a Lawyer. Gordy

Depends

@ November 26, 2004 4:13 PM in Is college best for everyone?

I truley believe Some of us are leaders some are followers but you need to enjoy what you are doing.Be a productive individual to society, and you have done the right thing with your life. I'm still a firm believer in starting in the mail room and working your way up from there in any trade needing degree or not, I feel this produces the most well rounded working individual and it was that way for years. This world was built by the tradesmen of all types,who were Pushed forward by the idealist,and the results studied by the scientist.We are all leading one another in this cycle. This is how society evolves.We all contribute to one another there is no I in the word "TEAM".Now just pick a position thats right for "YOU",and help make this world a better place. Be Happy Gordy

Weezbo

@ November 26, 2004 3:33 PM in Is college best for everyone?

You Crack me up!! You are right.:O

AIR

@ November 26, 2004 11:54 AM in 1952 House With Ceiling Radiant Heat

Its interesting to note the piping configuration in my system (parallel). At first when one looks at the main supply and returns, you wonder why they did some things especially on the main returns, but it all has to do with air, I soon learned.After purging Instead of chasing any remaining air around bleeding every loop in a total drain down, it will all come to 2 points on the return in the system. I could not get this in my head for a while because these two "collection points" are in the basement for the upstairs ceiling radiant. Thinking like air in a closed system can be tricky. Gordy

Lime

@ November 25, 2004 11:30 AM in Ceiling Radiant heat - copper tubing

So Hot Rod, being that lime is a base that is not playing a role correct. Going by some of the reading in the hot tech topics under "concrete corrodes pipes" here. Thanks for your clarification Hot Rod. Hmmm stray electrical current, bonding ones service to the water pipes per code may have consequences if something is not quite right. Gordy

Air

@ November 25, 2004 10:37 AM in 1952 House With Ceiling Radiant Heat

> Not too many compaired to floor............
> Serviced a few old ceiling radiant systems over
> the years with non diaphram expantion tanks and
> cirulators on the return. Air was a head ache
> along with the old crusty isolation butterfly
> valves....

@ November 25, 2004 10:35 AM in 1952 House With Ceiling Radiant Heat

Nice stuff, I have the Chase brass and copper propaganda with my system. Its interesting to see the point of view back then.

picture

@ November 25, 2004 10:29 AM in Ceiling Radiant heat - copper tubing

You got it. Lots of copper, at least thats how my system is. Looking at the picture I notice a couple of the tubing runs are like new and the majority have a gun blue or black finish to them what is their condition compared to the newer looking?

Paul

@ November 24, 2004 11:19 PM in Ceiling Radiant heat - copper tubing

Paul, elaborate on this reaction a little please. Gordy

@ November 24, 2004 10:39 PM in Ceiling Radiant heat - copper tubing

Exactly Mark. Sounds like a water quality issue, from what I have learned.Notting Mike that several systems you have dealt with did this. Mike are these all in the same area? Same water supply? Its nice to play a little detective work with issues like this ,it helps everyone out. No need for someone with a perfectly good system to tear it out on the premise its going to disintegrate. There are reasons and I doubt its the plaster.

Curious

@ November 24, 2004 9:26 PM in Ceiling Radiant heat - copper tubing

Curious to how you knew the copper was "rotting Out". Leaks?

No Hot Heads Please :-)

@ November 24, 2004 9:11 PM in 1952 House With Ceiling Radiant Heat

Hot rod, You are right about meeting the load. I think what makes my ceiling radiant comfortable is the close centers of the tubing, which allows lower water temps to meet the heat load of the dwelling. While the install of all that tubing is "so expensive" it does however creat a higher efficiency level after the fact. Lower water temps has to be more efficient. I would love to see the savings with a condensing boiler. I have to laugh at some internet claims that drive their open systems with huge bore tubing and extra wide centers. Whats next, "we could heat your house with 3" pex at 6' centers" look at the savings in tubing LOL. Not to mention the Free Cooling aspect. JMHO Gordy I have seen quite a few electric resistance systems in my area. Have not lived in that enviroment though. If its anything like cooking on an electric stove burner I would say it is hard to control.

@ November 24, 2004 8:53 PM in 1952 House With Ceiling Radiant Heat

Yes Mike, it is a plaster embedded system with 1/2" rock lathe as the backer for the plaster. You are right another lost art. There are so few left.