Joined on January 19, 2012
Last Post on April 23, 2014
@ April 23, 2014 12:01 AM in Modifications to Hydronic SystemYou have all the separation you need with option A.
Option B would give you lower temps at each branch. It would also require anther circ.
The bipass shown in the manual is intended for boiler flow protection. You have that covered with the closely spaced tees at the boiler.
All emitters (panel heaters) have a "sweet spot" which is the ideal amount of flow to produce the designed heat output. Once you go past that point, you don't gain very much output for your increase in flow.
I am not familiar with that Alpha and it's performance characteristics as it is not sold in North America.
You absolutely do not want to run the alpha at a fixed speed.I think with your setup you will be best off running it with the relatively flat curve medium head setting of PP2. Once the system is up and running you can measure the supply/return delta t and decide whether you want to change the setting. I think you likely have the right circulator for the application.
@ April 22, 2014 9:21 AM in Modifications to Hydronic SystemYou do not need the additional hydrolic separation in your second drawing. The drop in temp between the zones is really not desirable either.
The first drawings is pretty good.
Make sure the main header is sized for 2ft/sec (metric equiv.) max so the circs won't fight each other.
All zone circs should have a check valve.
The bipass valve is not needed or desirable with the alpha circ. It will maintain constant pressure without the wasted energy of bipassing.
@ April 19, 2014 9:08 AM in PEX pipe split (hydronic)Pex generally does really well with freezing. The problem you are likely seeing is that if most of run is completely incased and cannot expand, any part that is not completely encased, ends up expanding a disproportionate amount. I bet that part was sitting at the bottom of the slab. Another reason to center the tubes in the slab.
@ April 15, 2014 10:48 AM in The dreaded EntranOf course you will need a heat exchanger or the problem will never stop.
The real question is how do you keep it from plugging up?
What is really plugging the tubes?
If it is really the tubing falling apart, you have a bigger problem.
@ April 11, 2014 8:29 AM in New Circ Pump Flange 90 Degrees OffThe flanges are threaded, yes?
Use 2 pipe wrenches and take them off. Retape and or seal the threads,then thread them back on stopping in the position you desire. If you try to do this without taking it apart, you will likely end up with a leak.
@ April 10, 2014 8:28 AM in home ownerAs for the circulator sizing, it does not have to be anything elaborate. If you can say "it is about 100' of 3/4" pipe and the circulator is this model number", that would suffice.
Are the pinholes forming along the bottom of the straight sections of pipe or are the after a fitting?
At this point, I think you need to narrow this down. Do you have (or had) a water quality issue or is the problem velocity related.
@ April 9, 2014 9:19 AM in home ownerHot rod,
Are you thinking that the corrosion is creating a "corrosive cocktail" within the heating fluid?
Normally the O2 issue does not effect copper.
To the OP, Have you checked the PH of the system water?
@ April 8, 2014 11:15 PM in home ownerIf you have a zone with a frequent call for heat and the zone has too large a circulator, the pipe may be deteriorating due to high velocity water.If you post a picture of your boiler piping along with the model circulator and approx length and diameter pipe, that would help.
@ April 3, 2014 6:02 PM in Problems with Open radiant floor systemAlright, it looks like you have your mind made up on the "open" thing.
For me, I only had to see the stinky green slime in the tubes once and I am convinced it is a bad plan.
As for the check valve. What type do you have that is failing?
I wonder if a "dual check" like you would have on the service to a building would work better. Some can be disassembled and cleaned. Either way it sounds like it is a part that will continue to have issues, good isolation valves and unions will make the job easier.
@ April 3, 2014 5:42 PM in LAARS Endurance problemAre you turning down the thermostat in the house or something on the boiler?
Does the boiler also heat the domestic hot water?
@ April 3, 2014 2:03 PM in Problems with Open radiant floor systemThis is not about personal preference. It is about your health.Don't take my word for it. Take a sample of the water in your system and have it checked for legionella.
A heat exchanger set up is just not that expensive.
The system works fantastically , aside from poisoning the occupants.
"Aside from that Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play?"
@ April 3, 2014 8:19 AM in what is the maximuin water flow through 1 inch copper at 50 psiShould calculate all this. He should also look at the capacity of the well to see if it can keep up.Since the well is also a fire pump it may need to be wired differently.
He should have already looked at this as his system should be designed based on available GPM and PSI.
@ April 2, 2014 11:33 PM in Auto fill/back flow preventer. Is it necessary?I think what you have will work.
It is to bad you can't dual purpose the DHW tank to give you some more system buffer.
Have you considered putting a reverse indirect buffer/dhw tank on the heating side?
Wood boilers need something to heat, they don't idle well.
@ April 2, 2014 11:17 PM in LAARS Endurance problemHow are you adjusting the temp?
How are the 2 boilers controlled?
Turning down the temp on a non-condensing boiler can damage the boiler.
Can you post some pictures?
@ April 2, 2014 11:01 PM in what is the maximuin water flow through 1 inch copper at 50 psiFire systems are a whole different game.
In most areas the whole thing including the well and pump need to be designed by an engineer.
I think it is safe to say that your 1" line will not be big enough.
@ April 2, 2014 6:53 PM in what is the maximuin water flow through 1 inch copper at 50 psiI think the max flow rate for cold water that most codes allow is 8 feet per second. At that rate you could move 18-22 gpm depending on the wall thickness of your pipe.Ideally you would not move it that fast as it could wear out your pipes. I think the flow rates in the above post is a better idea (about 6fps).
The pressure drop at those rates should not be an issue (less than 5psi).
If you are wondering how fast the water could move through the pipe,if you left the end open. The answer is ALOT!
@ April 2, 2014 6:02 PM in Auto fill/back flow preventer. Is it necessary?Your heating piping has an extra circ. There is no need for the primary loop and closely spaced tees. You could instead run your 2 mixing loops right off the exchangers. You just need a beefy header size and check valves on the circs.
The same applies to the owb and hot water heating piping. Right now the water heater is heating a cold wood boiler.
@ April 2, 2014 5:29 PM in Weil McLain indirect hot water heater, short cycling?..I am assuming that the indirect is a zone that is being prioritized by the Taco?
The first thing I would do is be sure it is not a control issue. Does the zone valve open?
If you manually open the zone valve and jumper the TT to the boiler does the problem go away? A flaky contact in the indirects aquastat, zone valve end switch or taco relay could be causing this.
If the control side checks out, I would then check for proper circulation then start trouble shooting the boiler.
@ April 2, 2014 11:47 AM in Hot Water Tanks and SizesYou have fairly low hot water requirements.
It sounds like you are trying to decide between an indirect and an electric.
What is heating your hot water presently? How well does it work?
What type of boiler do you have? What fuel does it run on?
If you have an oversized oil boiler, the electric is usually a good option as it saves you money in the summer.
If you have a high efficiency gas boiler, the indirect is usually a good call.
@ April 1, 2014 9:06 AM in How To Make Current System More EfficientDo you have hot water baseboard?
What model are the boilers?
Have you purchased the buffer tank? Does it have 4 ports so it can be used as a hydrolic separator?
Depending on the answers to the above questions, I think the ideal plan would be to have the 2 boilers piped in parallel on one side of the buffer tank/ separator. The heat manifolds would come off the other side.
You will save electrical circulator energy by going with zone valves and ECM.circ. You need to pump away from the expansion tank .
Outdoor reset will not help much with efficiency as both boilers are non condensing. It may help with comfort.
The controls are pretty simple. Keep the buffer tank at a certain temp using a 2 boiler controller with an adjustable differential to assure long cycle times.
@ March 31, 2014 1:20 PM in Modcons in Closets-I believe they are concerned that the limited space inside the closet will cause the room to get too warm which would potentially over heat the flue pipe.
Install per manual with PP piping and you should be all set.
@ March 31, 2014 9:03 AM in Coming From the"High"Country CO...(Altitude not Attitude:-)Richard,
What system are you on? You might try another browser.
I will sometimes copy my text an bigger posts in case the system malfunctions.
I am interested in your thoughts on this one....